SPEAKER_01 8:21–11:26
Hello Bill. I'd like to start a discussion that's probably in line with what Zach was just talking about except with the knee, funny enough. So we'll run through this. I have an older gentleman who really should give up lifting. He's not too smart, but he decides that he keeps doing it anyway. He's got a bung right knee—well, both truth be known—both of his knees are screwed up. When I do a split squat, if I move down and put my right leg back, then when I get to the bottom of the split squat, I get anterior knee pain, which we've discussed before. I've been having a discussion with a couple of physios at the gym about your explanation based on the model of what might be occurring there, and comparing it to the traditional knee tracking model with one muscle pulling relative to another. Just to make sure I'm clear on my explanation to them, because I've said, 'Please bear with me and I'll explain it as best I can.' I've explained that essentially I'm trying to achieve an 'eye on a yard structure' for lack of a better explanation. My feet are really out on the outside edges, and I have a lot of difficulty getting the medial first met head down and medial foot contact. The foot is in an ER representation, the tibia is ER out, and I've even got maybe a slight hint of bowing—not a lot, but a little bit. When I go to move down, I reach a point just below what might be the max IR moment at the bottom, and that's where the pain kicks in. I did a little self-test where I really oriented my lumbar spine or pelvis and took up some of the IR in the lumbar spine to see whether that would affect the descent. It did—I could get down much further without pain. So I thought, 'I'm on track; I need to pull myself into an early representation and then superimpose some IR on that to clear this up.' I did this with a ramped fake med ball throw: a staggered stand, initially to adjust with a fake med ball throw for a few sets, which gave me some relief. Then I added a ramp to the lead leg and knocked out about four sets of five, and retested—fantastic, it cleared right up. Now, for the explanation to the physios, they were obviously looking at patella tracking and talking about muscle imbalances. They manipulated my knee during some of this to see whether that reduced the pain; it didn't change the patella at all. Once I went through the sequence and cleared it up, they asked me about it. I had the thought that while I'm in a lead leg split squat, I'm not super strong, but I'm strong enough to know that when my rear foot is back in a split squat, I should be able to push up without the quad muscles needing to work hard enough for a muscular imbalance to affect patella tracking. It occurred to me that if the muscles are under very low load or at rest, how could a muscular imbalance even make sense? Do you know what I mean?
knee mechanicsexternal rotationinternal rotationmuscle imbalancejoint pain