Bill Hartman 27:26–30:27
I kind of did a full academic assessment because it's kind of lacking in the academic kind of things. You know, I just, I think in general it, I find it silly to exclude food groups for no reason. Right. Right. And so, you know, like when people say like, Oh, I like, I don't eat this. And you're like, Oh, why? And they're like, Oh, it's not good for you. And it's like, you know, but like for no given reason, they're just decided it was magically not good for them. So with the carnivore diet to say like, you just eat meat. And, you know, so what's the difference between a carnivore diet and a ketogenic diet. So if we added seven spears of asparagus each day, right, and three mushrooms, like all of a sudden you lose all these magical effects of said carnivore diet. So those kind of huge like chasms of logic when those are missing, I find it really difficult to have conversations about should or shouldn't you do that. There's no good There's no good biological mechanism really behind it. You know, I think really if we look at time, the closest thing you'd liken to would be a ketogenic diet. And if you look at the data behind ketogenic diet, which from a sports performance perspective is really lacking. I actually did a webinar yesterday on it. And I did a review last fall on it as well, like an academic review. And it just, there is a lot of good data on sports performance and ketogenic diet. And so at best, it's just as good as a regular dietary approach. potentially better at endurance, but likely insufficient at high intensities, right, even after keto adaptation. So if you kind of apply all those same things to the carnivore diet, I mean, you know, that's kind of what you're left with. I think there are a lot easier dietary patterns for people to follow. I mean, I love your advice. So it's like, I think that, you know, but I also think that when you start excluding whole food groups, you know, your personal biology and physiology doesn't change because you've decided to eat or not to eat certain things. So this is a conversation I always have with people if they follow a vegetarian diet, like that's fine. But like the biology of your protein metabolism is still the thing. Like your body still needs two to three grams of leucine at every eating occasion to maximize muscle protein synthesis. Just because you're choosing not to eat, foods that are high in these essential amino acids doesn't change your body's need for it. And so when you look at these other extreme dietary approaches, you're like, okay, that's fine, but what are we doing to account for now all the things that we're not getting that we generally would have otherwise that your body needs?
carnivore dietketogenic dietvegetarian dietamino acidsmuscle protein synthesis